Curvature — the series · Machine Kinematics

The mechanism drops out

Every other field here is about a machine. This one is about the motion a machine makes — a plane sliding over a plane — and near any instant that motion is a handful of numbers with no linkage in them. Two mechanisms that agree on those numbers make the same motion, and one of them can always be thrown away.

part 1 · curvature

A point, its pole, and the centre it is turning about. The tracing point is on the coupler at (0.45, 0.5) of its length. The cross is the pole, the faint curve is the path the point traces over a whole turn, and the circle is the one that path is momentarily on — centre marked, radius 0.267. The point, the pole and the centre are collinear, which is not an accident of this position: a point's centre of curvature always lies on its own ray from the pole, and Euler and Savary's relation says where on it. Here that relation puts the centre 5.6e-16 of a unit from where differentiating the loop equation three times puts it. positioned by solving, not by drawing.

Every point has a centre

A point of a moving plane traces a curve, and near an instant that curve is a circle. Which circle is decided by one relation with two numbers in it — the same relation for every point of the plane at once, and it was written down in 1830 with no derivatives visible anywhere in it.

part 2 · curvature

The circle of points going straight

At any instant some points of a moving plane are travelling in a straight line. They form a circle — not nearly a circle, a circle — and the reason is one real coefficient in a quadratic. A coupler curve has an inflection exactly when that circle sweeps over the tracing point, which turns out to be rare.

part 2 · curvature

Two poles at 66°, and only one of them is still. The stubs here are accelerations, not velocities, and they vanish at a different point from the one where the velocities vanish. The cross is the velocity pole — the point the plane is turning about — and the square is the acceleration pole, the point that is momentarily not accelerating. Over a full turn of this crank the two are never nearer than 1.49 coupler lengths and get as far apart as 22.2. The instantaneous centre is about velocities and about nothing else: the point that is not moving is being accelerated, usually hard, and a body pivoting about it in the ordinary sense would not be. positioned by solving, not by drawing.

The other pole

The instantaneous centre is the point of a moving plane that is not moving. There is a second point that is not accelerating, it is somewhere else entirely, and over a full turn of one four-bar the two are never closer than one and a half coupler lengths and get as far apart as twenty-two.

part 3 · curvature

The collineation axis at 66°. The coupler line extended and the frame line extended meet at Q, and the line from the pole through Q is the collineation axis. Bobillier's theorem is that the axis and the pole tangent make equal angles with the two rays PA and PB, in opposite senses — so having the axis gives the pole tangent, which is otherwise the one quantity here that needs the motion differentiated. Measured over 50 pairs of conjugate points the relation holds to 2.5e-14 radians. positioned by solving, not by drawing.

A construction with no arithmetic in it

Everything in this field so far has needed the motion differentiated. Bobillier's theorem gets the pole tangent — the one quantity that otherwise needs a derivative — out of two lines that are already drawn on the mechanism, and the inflection circle follows from three points and a pair of compasses.

part 3 · curvature

Where the curvature is standing still, at 66°. The cubic of stationary curvature: every point on it traces a path whose curvature has stopped changing at this instant, so its osculating circle fits for one order longer than an ordinary point's. It passes through the pole — twice, with a double point there — and through both moving pins, which is the plainest case there is, since a pin traces an exact circle and a constant curvature is certainly a stationary one. The expression whose zero set this is looks like a quartic and its fourth-degree terms cancel to 1.2e-14 of the third-degree ones. positioned by solving, not by drawing.

Where the curvature stands still

One derivative further on there is a second locus: the points whose path curvature has momentarily stopped changing. The expression whose zero set it is looks like a quartic, its fourth-degree terms cancel, and the cancellation is measured at ten to the minus fourteen rather than assumed.

part 4 · curvature

Ball's point at 66°. Two curves and one point. The circle is the locus of points whose path is momentarily straight; the cubic is the locus of points whose path curvature is momentarily not changing. A point on both has a path that is straight and staying straight — four-point contact with its own tangent line, one order better than anything else in the plane. That is Ball's point. Walking the circle and looking for a zero of κ′ turned up 1 sign changes here and 1 of them survived being checked for continuity — the others are the asymptote the pole itself produces. Its measured order of contact with the line is 3.95. positioned by solving, not by drawing.

The straightest point there is

Where the circle of points going straight meets the cubic of points whose curvature is standing still, there is one point whose path is straight and staying straight. Neither Watt nor Chebyshev put their tracing point there, and moving Watt's to it more than halves the error over the whole stroke.

part 4 · curvature

Four positions brought together

Burmester's construction finds the points of a moving plane whose four prescribed positions lie on a circle. Bring the four positions together and the curve it draws has to become the cubic of stationary curvature — and the gap between the two closes as the square of the spread, with the exponent measured rather than assumed.

part 5 · curvature

A corner in a curve, and the reason for it. This coupler point traces a curve with a cusp — a corner, where the curve stops and reverses rather than turning. The reason is that a cusp happens where the tracing point is momentarily still, and the only point of a moving plane that is momentarily still is the pole. So the cusps of a coupler curve are the instants when the pole passes through the tracing point: they are the crossings of the tracing point by the moving centrode, which is a statement about two curves in the coupler's own plane with the fixed plane not involved at all. This point was chosen by taking the pole's body coordinate at one instant, so it is on the moving centrode by construction; at the corner its speed is 9.9e-15 against 2.87 a fifth of a radian later. positioned by solving, not by drawing.

Where a curve has a corner

Some coupler curves have corners in them — points where the curve stops, turns round and comes back. A corner happens where the tracing point is momentarily still, the only point of a moving plane that is momentarily still is the pole, and so the corners of a coupler curve are decided entirely inside the coupler's own plane.

part 5 · curvature

Two circles, and an exact straight line. The moving centrode of this motion is a circle of radius 1.5 and the fixed one is a circle of radius 3.0, measured to 8.9e-16. The small circle rolls inside the large one, and a point on its rim traces a diameter of the large one — exactly, with no error term. Watt's linkage is straight to nine per cent of its span and Chebyshev's to twelve; this is straight to 0.0e+0, and the difference is not one of degree. It is the difference between a curve that approximates a line and two centrodes whose rolling produces one. positioned by solving, not by drawing.

Exact because two circles roll

Watt's straight line is straight to nine parts in a hundred and Chebyshev's to twelve. Here is one that is straight to nothing at all — no error term, no working range, no approximation anywhere — and the reason is that its two centrodes are circles, one rolling inside the other at exactly half its radius.

part 6 · curvature

Two Burmester points, or none, depending where the crank is. A Burmester point's path stays on one circle to fifth order. A planar motion has at most four of them; two of this mechanism's are always its own moving pins, whose paths are exact circles and satisfy every order at once. The other two are real for 67 per cent of the turn and complex for the rest, and the count changes without anything about the mechanism changing. The window matters and is stated: points beyond a hundred coupler lengths from the pole are not counted, and widening the window from six to four hundred moves the count of positions-with-two from 191 to 245 out of 360. A silent cap here would read as an absence.

The circle a point stays on longest

One condition further on are the points whose path holds a circle to fifth order. A planar motion has at most four; two of them are always the mechanism's own pins, and the other two are real for two thirds of a turn and complex for the rest — a count that changes while nothing about the mechanism does.

part 6 · curvature

Three points, three orders of contact. Replace the coupler point by a crank pivoting at the centre of its path's osculating circle, drive the linkage away from the instant, and measure how far the point gets from that circle. The distance grows like a power of the step, and the power is the number of derivatives that agreed. An ordinary point gives 3.00; a point of the cubic of stationary curvature gives 3.94; a Burmester point, where the curvature is stationary and its rate of change is too, gives 4.97. Nothing in the measurement knows which kind of point it was handed. This is what the two special curves are for: they are where a single pivot can replace a whole linkage for longest. positioned by solving, not by drawing.

How long a pivot stands in for a linkage

Throw the four-bar away and replace a coupler point by a crank pivoting at the centre of its path's curvature. The two separate like the cube of the crank step for an ordinary point, the fourth power on the cubic, and the fifth at a Burmester point — three exponents that are the whole field, measured with no derivative anywhere in the measurement.

part 7 · curvature

The two curves the pole rolls along, at 60°. The pole is a different point at every instant, and it traces one curve in the fixed plane and another in the moving one. Those are the centrodes, and the whole motion is the second rolling without slipping on the first — a statement with no mechanism in it, which is why two completely different linkages with the same centrodes produce the same motion. The moving centrode is drawn here in the position it occupies at this instant, and it touches the fixed one at the pole to 0.0e+0 of a unit. positioned by solving, not by drawing.

The linkage, put back from two curves

This field opened by saying the mechanism drops out, and that every planar motion is one curve rolling on another. Both are true and neither had been measured. The rolling reproduces the four-bar's own placement to a residual that quarters when the sampling halves, and the two curves lay equal arc to a part in a billion.

part 8 · curvature

Three circles at one point, at 50°. The osculating circle of the fixed centrode at the pole, the osculating circle of the moving centrode there, and the inflection circle. All three pass through the pole and all three have their centres on the common normal — which is what makes the relation between them a relation between three numbers on a line. The two centrode radii are 16.180 and 9.730, signed along that normal, and the inflection circle's diameter is 24.398 against the 24.409 the other two give. Nothing in that arithmetic knows there is a linkage. The window is 30.25 wide and the larger osculating circle is 32.36 across, so it is cut at the edge: what is drawn is the neighbourhood of the pole, where the three curvatures are the same three numbers however far the circles carrying them reach.

The two numbers are the curves' own

Every essay in this field runs on the inflection circle and the pole tangent, and every one has taken them from the motion's derivatives. They are the two centrodes' radii of curvature at the pole, combined harmonically — measurable off the curves with no mechanism in the arithmetic, and carrying a sign that changes eight times in a turn.

part 9 · curvature

Holding the coupler still: the frame's inflection circle is the mirror of the coupler's. The four-bar with ground 4, crank 1, coupler 3.5 and rocker 3 at a crank angle of 225°, redrawn in the coupler's own frame, so the coupler is the horizontal bar and the ground link is what moves. The circle on one side of the pole is the ordinary inflection circle — coupler points travelling straight — carried into this frame. The circle on the other side is the inverse motion's: frame points travelling straight when the coupler is held. It is computed by differentiating the swap and, separately, by solving the coupler-held four-bar, and both routes put it at the first circle reflected through the pole, to 7e-15 on a radius of 4.45. The line through the pole is the common tangent. Dragging the crank angle moves both circles and they stay mirror images.

The frame seen from the coupler

Hold a four-bar's coupler still and let its frame move, and every construction of the curvature field has a counterpart. The frame's points that travel straight lie on the ordinary inflection circle reflected through the pole — found by differentiating the swap and, independently, by solving the coupler-held four-bar, both to 10⁻¹⁴ — and a point and the centre of curvature of its path trade places exactly. The inverse motion of one four-bar is the ordinary motion of another.

part 10 · curvature

A curvature is a size with a minus sign

Everything in the curvature field is a similarity invariant in shape and a reciprocal length in value. Scale a moving plane and its inflection circle scales, its cubic of stationary curvature scales, and every curvature it computes is divided by the factor — so a bigger machine traces gentler paths than its drawing suggests.

part 13 · curvature

The acceleration pole walks round the inflection circle. The four-bar of this field — ground 4, crank 1, coupler 3.5, rocker 3 — at a crank angle of 240°, with its inflection circle, the locus of coupler points whose paths are momentarily straight, of diameter 9.23. The cross is the velocity pole and the ring is the far end of the diameter from it, the inflection pole. The square is the acceleration pole when the crank is driven with an angular acceleration of 0.323 times its angular speed squared. It is on the circle, at 30.0° from the diameter, which is arctan of the coupler's angular acceleration over its angular speed squared. The circle does not move when the drive changes; only the square does. Dragging changes the crank's acceleration.

The other pole is on the circle

The point of a moving plane with no acceleration depends on how fast the input is driven, which is why it was set apart from the rest of this field as the one object that is not geometry. It is not free, though. It always lies on the inflection circle — the geometric locus of points going straight — at an angle from the circle's diameter whose tangent is the plane's angular acceleration over its angular speed squared. A drive chooses one angle, and the geometry has already chosen everything else.

part 14 · curvature

The third-order pole goes where the drive puts it. The four-bar of this field at a crank angle of 60°, with its inflection circle. The cross is the velocity pole and the ring Ball's point, where the circle meets the cubic of stationary curvature. The square is the third-order pole — the coupler point whose jerk is nought — when the crank is driven with an angular acceleration of 1 and a jerk of 6, each per the right power of its speed. It is at (0.492, 10.663). The faint curve is where it goes as the jerk alone is varied: a circle through the velocity pole. Every point off the inflection circle is the third-order pole of exactly one drive; on the circle only the velocity pole and Ball's point can be. Dragging changes the drive.

The third pole goes anywhere but the circle

The velocity pole is fixed by the geometry and the acceleration pole by the geometry up to one number, its place on the inflection circle. The next one, the point of a moving plane whose jerk is nought, depends on two numbers of the drive — and two numbers are enough to put it anywhere. Every point of the plane off the inflection circle is the third-order pole of exactly one drive, because a body point's jerk is affine in the crank's acceleration and jerk. On the circle only two points qualify: the velocity pole, and Ball's point, where the path is straight to third order.

part 15 · curvature

The crank's acceleration fixes its jerk, so the two numbers a point needs cannot both be met. For the coupler point (0.45, 0.5) of the standard four-bar, over the crank's stroke from 30° to 150°: the second schedule number λ = θ⃛/θ̇³ that, with the first κ = θ̈/θ̇², makes the point's jerk nought at each angle; and the λ that a crank actually following that κ has, κ′ + 2κ², since both numbers come from one function, the crank's speed against its angle. Their difference, the mismatch, reaches 1.77 and is nought only at 39.8°. Wherever it is not nought no crank holds the point's jerk at nought.

No drive holds the third pole

At one crank angle a drive's acceleration and jerk can put the coupler's third-order pole on almost any point, making that point's jerk nought. Over a stretch of the stroke they cannot. A crank's schedule is one function, its speed against its angle, and its jerk number is fixed by its acceleration number: λ = κ′ + 2κ². So the two numbers a point needs at every angle must satisfy that relation, and on the standard four-bar they miss it by as much as the numbers themselves, agreeing only at isolated angles. The best schedule a crank can follow takes a fifth to a third off a coupler point's jerk, and no more.

part 16 · curvature

Where on the coupler a scheduled crank is smoothest. The standard four-bar's coupler plane, A at the origin and B at (1, 0), shaded darker where a point's jerk per unit of its own travel over the stroke from 30° to 150° is smaller, with the crank's speed scheduled to make that point's jerk least: from 1.34 to 5.12, measured in time over a stroke of fixed duration. The smoothest scheduled point is (−0.02, −0.80), at 1.263 against 4.555 with a steady crank; the smoothest with a steady crank is (−1.00, 1.25), at 3.397. Ball's point at the stroke's middle lies at (1.55, 3.27), off the map, where it scores 1.702 scheduled.

The smoothest coupler point is chosen in time

A crank's speed can be scheduled to cut a coupler point's jerk, though never to nought. Which point should a designer free to choose it pick? Measured as the schedule essays measured jerk, per crank speed cubed, the answer is a point whose schedule swings the crank's speed four to one, and it is a cheat: that measure divides by the speed it changes. Measured in time over a stroke of fixed duration, per unit of the point's own travel, the smoothest point of the standard four-bar is (−0.02, −0.80) in the coupler's frame. Its schedule cuts its jerk by 72% with a speed swing under two to one, and it is 63% smoother than the best a steady crank finds anywhere. Ball's point, the instant's straightest, lies in a second, shallower valley four coupler lengths away.

part 17 · curvature

A crank that must come round picks another point

A crank scheduled over one stroke can cut the smoothest coupler point's jerk by 72%. A crank running continuously must come back to the speed it started at, and its working stroke must keep its share of the cycle. Held to both, the same point keeps two-thirds of its gain only by putting five and a half times a steady crank's jerk into the return, and no schedule beats a steady crank on both strokes. Choose the point for the whole turn instead and a gentle schedule, its speed swinging only 1.66 to one, cuts the working stroke's jerk by 74% and the return's by 18% together. That point is three coupler lengths from the first.

part 18 · curvature