Machine Kinematics
solved, then drawn
Concept

Independence — where it appears

The property of a set of constraints or motions that none of them is implied by the others. It is decided by a rank rather than by inspection, and the difference between counting and measuring it is where overconstraint lives.

Named by 2 essays across one field — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Two ways of adding four tolerances. The output band from ±0.01 on each of four lengths, combined two ways. The upper curve is worst case — every error at its extreme and conspiring — and the lower is root-sum-square, which treats the four as independent random errors. RSS is smaller everywhere, by between 1.42 and 1.95, and with four contributions the most it can ever be is √4 = 2. That factor is not a saving found in the geometry; it is bought with the assumption that the four errors are independent, and one fixture that locates two of the holes takes it straight back.

Worst case and the square root

Four tolerances can be added as a straight sum or as a root-sum-square, and the second is smaller by between 1.42 and 1.96 through this linkage's cycle. The ceiling is √4 = 2 and no geometry can beat it. That factor is not found in the mechanism — it is bought entirely with an assumption of independence, and one fixture that locates two holes takes it straight back.

practice · Tolerance Tolerancing the holes rather than the lengths. The output band from ±0.01, computed on the four link lengths and then on the features those lengths are derived from. The ground length is the distance between two frame holes, and what happens to it depends entirely on how they were made: located separately, two independent errors combine to √2 times one and the lengths-only answer is optimistic by 11%; bored in one setup, the common part of the machine's error cancels out of the distance between them and the lengths-only answer is pessimistic by 34%. Neither is a correction to apply; it is a question for the machine shop, and this site can compute the sensitivity and not the answer.

Tolerancing the holes

A drawing does not tolerance link lengths. It tolerances holes, and the lengths are derived from them — so what a length's tolerance really means depends on whether its two holes were bored in one setup. Located separately, a lengths-only stack-up is optimistic by 11%; bored together, it is pessimistic by 34%. Neither is a correction to apply blind.

practice · Tolerance

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

AllocationAverageConstraintDerivativeFour-barJacobianSensitivityThresholdToleranceDatumStroke

All concepts